N
Common Ground News

Why is Amir surprised that Baba says he is going to become a great writer?

Author

Olivia Shea

Updated on February 28, 2026

Why is Amir surprised that Baba says he is going to become a great writer?

Instead of protecting someone who had devoted his life to him, Amir was selfish. He feels he will pay for this choice in the future. Why is Amir surprised that Baba says he is going to become a "great" writer? Baba disapproves and says Amir's degree will be useless.

Also know, who says Amir is going to be a great writer to General Taheri?

Baba

One may also ask, what is ironic about Baba's statement? Baba kept his secret through death, and Hassan died never knowing who his father was. This is an example of irony because the character traits that Baba taught to Amir were the opposite of what he practiced in his own life.

Additionally, why does Amir want to be a writer?

Rahim Khan encouraged Amir to keep writing when he was young, and that led to Amir following his dream of becoming a creative writer. He knew it was important to believe in Amir because writing was a passion that Amir loved and he knew not every kid wanted to be a cookie cutter doctor.

How does Amir start down the road of becoming a writer?

He acts in a play with Hassan. He discovers stories his father wrote.

Why did Baba sleep with Sanaubar?

The reason because Baba slept with Sanaubar was maybe because He didn't wanted her to be devoid of motherhood and Ali may had consented to this too for the same reasons.

How does Baba die?

A month after the wedding the Taheris and some other friends come over for a big dinner. Amir can tell that Baba is happy watching him and Soraya together. Baba dies in his sleep that night. Baba finally starts to give Amir the approval and support he craved so much as a boy.

What did Baba say about Amir?

Perhaps the most dramatic quote from Baba about Amir comes when he says, ''A boy who won't stand up for himself becomes a man who can't stand up to anything. '' This reflects Baba's concern over Amir's courage and willingness to stand up for what is right.

What does Soraya confess to Amir?

Amir asks his father to arrange his marriage with Soraya. What does Soraya confess to Amir? come home. Amir wishes Rahim Khan was at his wedding and wonders if Hassan ever married.

What does Baba say is the only sin?

Baba tells him that there is only one sin: theft. Every other sin is a variation of theft. Murdering a man, for instance, is stealing his life.

Does Amir become a writer?

Baba is not one hundred percent pleased with Amir's decision on becoming a writer but this decision made Baba view Amir in a more manly way. He always wanted Amir to govern his own life and because of this he know longer sees Amir as a young boy who can not stand his ground.

How is Amir selfish?

Part of the reason Amir is selfish is that Baba, his father, restricts his love toward his son and is very critical of him. Later, when Amir chooses to adopt Hassan's son after Hassan's death, he has become truly selfless. The guilt he suffered as a boy caused him to become less selfish and more mature.

Why did Hassan still love Amir?

Hassan loves Amir without limits or conditions. Despite Amir's betrayal, however, Hassan's love for his friend never wavers. It is his letter, years after their parting, that puts Amir on the road to redemption and self-respect. Thus, Hassan saves Amir twice, once as a boy and years later, even after his own death.

Are Amir and Hassan brothers?

Hassan was actually the son of Sanaubar and Baba, making him Amir's half brother. Finally, Khan tells Amir that the reason he has called Amir to Pakistan is to ask him to rescue Hassan's son, Sohrab, from an orphanage in Kabul.

Why is Amir jealous of Hassan?

Amir envies Hassan when his father shows him affection in the form of attention and gifts. Amir sees Hassan as a threat to his relationship between him and his father, which is spurred by his jealous nature. He wants his father to only show him attention and not show Hassan father-like love.

Does Amir still crave his father's approval?

Amir gained his father's acceptance for a short time, but it faded away. Amir tried the rest of his father's life to please him. He became educated, he married the right woman, he cared for his father, and in the end he never truly felt love from his father.

Why does Baba disapprove of Amir?

Baba's disapproval comes from his notion of masculinity. Baba is a successful businessman and expects his son to follow in his footsteps. Baba is troubled when he feels Amir is nothing like him; he even states at one point that if he hadn't seen Amir born, he wouldn't believe Amir was his son.

How does Amir become good again?

Expert Answers

Amir becomes good again by returning to Afghanistan and rescuing Sohrab, who, he discovers is his nephew. Since he had failed Hassan when they were both children, this is a form of redemption for him.

Is Amir a Pashtun?

Amir is the narrator and protagonist of the novel and is a Pashtun and Sunni Muslim. Although not a completely sympathetic character, Amir is one for whom most readers feel compassion. Amir has conflicted feelings about his father, Baba, and his playmate, Hassan.

Are Amir and Hassan friends?

In The Kite Runner, Amir and Hassan are close friends who come from different classes. As children, Hassan lives in Amir's family's house—his father is a family servant. However, he shares a deep friendship with Amir. The two are playmates and run around playing as long as Hassan does not have any chores or work to do.

How is Hassan's death ironic?

How is Hassan's death ironic? Amir is devastated by the news of Hassan's death, which is ironic because with all of the guilt Amir carries, he can never redeem himself. It's almost like Hassan suffered two deaths….. one as a child, and one as a man.

What is Baba's greatest fear?

register and alleviated one of his greatest fears: that an Afghan would see him buying food with charity money. Baba walked out of the welfare office like a man cured of a tumor.

Why does Baba challenge the Russian officer?

Mainly because Russia is invading them and they need to get out of Afghanistan. Why does Baba challenge the Russian officer who is obviously high on drugs? Foreshadowing because he is leaving Afghanistan. Kamal's father commits suicide after Kamal dies from breathing the fumes of the tank.

Who are the only three real men?

and meet your next favorite book! There are only three real men in this world, Amir," he'd say. He'd count them off on his fingers: America the brash saviour, Britain and Israel. "The rest of them-" he used to wave his hand and make a phht sound "-they're like gossiping old women.

How does Amir finally stand up to Baba in America?

What does Amir like about America? For Amir, America was an escape from his memories of Hassan. How does Amir finally stand up to Baba? He stood up to Baba by telling him that he wanted to be a creative writer instead of a doctor or lawyer.

How is America different for Baba and Amir?

Amir claims to use America to "bury my memories," whereas, for Baba, it is a place "to mourn his." Amir embraces America and all it has to offer as a means to escape the ghost of Hassan that was haunting his life in Afghanistan.

How is Baba different in America?

In The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini, Baba is different in the US than he is in Afghanistan. Baba is an important person in Afghanistan. He is wealthy. The home he and Amir share in Afghanistan is described as “Baba's mansion.” By comparison, in the US, he is an immigrant who cannot speak English very well.

What type of irony is used in Kite Runner?

The novel's greatest irony, and its most tragic, centers on Amir's choice not to stop Hassan's rape. Amir doesn't intervene because he wants Baba's approval, which he knows he can earn by bringing home the kite and proving that he, like Baba, is a winner.

What do Amir and Baba celebrate in the summer of 1983?

Amir graduates from high school in the summer of 1983 and Baba tells him, “I am moftakhir (proud), Amir.” At the celebration of his graduation that night, Baba tells the restaurant owner that Amir will be going to college that fall. Amir argues that he should get a job and save some money to go the following year.

WHO encourages Amir to write?

Lesson Summary

Rahim Khan is a minor character in Khaled Hosseini's The Kite Runner, but nevertheless he plays an important role. Early in the novel, he is Baba's close friend and business partner and a father figure to Amir. It's Rahim Khan who encourages Amir's writing.

What weakness of Amir's does Baba apologize for?

What "weakness" of Amir's does Baba have to apologize for in chapter 10? Baba apologizes for Amir's car sickness.

Who is Hassan's real father?

In order to motivate Amir to go to Kabul to save Sohrab, and thus, to amend for the wrongs committed against Hassan when he and Amir were children, Rahim Khan reveals that Ali was sterile and Baba is Hassan's biological father.

Where do Baba and Amir stay while the truck is being fixed?

Where do Amir and Baba stay while the truck is being fixed? They stay in a basement.

Who asks Amir to Pakistan?

Rahim calls Amir and asks him to come to Pakistan to see him.

How does Amir finally find redemption?

Amir redeems himself at the end of The Kite Runner when he adopts Hassan's son Sohrab. His friend Rahim Khan even acknowledges that there “is a way to be good again,” which is a clear signal that Amir can win redemption by raising Sohrab.

Why does Amir laugh when Assef beats him?

Before he challenges Amir to a fight, Assef tells a story about the time he was imprisoned. He says he began to laugh as a guard kicked him because it ended the pain he suffered from his kidney stone. Amir's laughing, though stemming from the relief of a different pain, clearly mirrors Assef's.

Is Kite Runner a true story?

No, The Kite Runner is not a true story. However, even though the characters in the story are fictional, many of the larger events depicted in the

What is Rahim's dying wish?

Rahim Khan's dying wish was for Amir to go back to Kabul, and get Sohrab, Hassan's son, and bring him to an American couple, Mr. and Mrs. Caldwell, who would then take care of him. In a way, Rahim Khan was doing Amir a favor, because he was giving him a chance to finally forgive himself for what he did to Hassan.